I have discussed this action with the expert group and they have agreed that this is appropriate given the current circumstances outlined in the note sent to the group on 3/31 and attached here. "Now that JSRs 207 and 208 have been approved by the EC, it is time for us to decide what the appropriate action should be on JSR 159. Originally, the goal of JSR 159 was to extend the existing J2EE component models to be more composable using a port based messaging model. As things progressed in the web service space, it became clear that web services were on the path to deliver this functionality. With J2EE 1.4, both servlets and EJBs can implement WSDL ports and use WSDL ports. This has effectively overlaid a universal, message based composition model over J2EE components. JSR 207 will now take over the extension of this model to include the control flow, state management, compensation, and sync-asynch merger that is needed for stateful web services in general and business processes in particular. JSR 208 will define a WSDL based communications model that will be the core of a J2EE environment. This WSDL based model will be used to loosely couple coarse grained 'components' within a service as well as communicate with external services. A unified view that merges components and services was an original goal of 159. I believe the combination of J2EE 1.4 web service support with JSRs 207 and 208 will accomplish the original goals of 159 in a way that is more in concert with web services standards. Therefore, I'm recommending that we terminate JSR 159."